Blog Archives

Malory Towers – Book Review

I was sick with the flu at the beginning of the year and I wanted a read that I didn’t have to think about too much – cue a re-read of some childhood favourites. I loved Malory Towers (by Enid Blyton) when I first read them (I think I’ve re-read them a few times since, my books are quite well thumbed – I also have the audiotape [yes tape] of the first book).
Now reading them as an adult (in 2013 – the first book was published in 1946!!) and a writer I have to admit to not being 100% as enamoured as I once had been but still enjoying and even remembering the stories.
I’m not a fan of the new cartoony covers preferring the ones from my copies (1990). I appreciate the need to attract a new generation (there have been many other illustrations which you can see on the Enid Blyton society website) but I wonder if the old fashioned language etc will come as even more of a shock with an up to date cover?
I can’t find the quote now but the series introduced me to the word prig – which sadly I’ve never had cause to use as an insult!!

I’m going to briefly review the 6 books and highlight why each one made me want to actually go to Malory Towers, what I liked about it and in some cases why I wasn’t as keen. May be some spoilers.

IMG_1426

First Term at Malory Towers (4 out of 5 stars)
We meet and immediately warm to Darrell Rivers and experience her wonder at her new school Malory Towers. I was especially jealous of their swimming pool which is refreshed by sea water daily.
We are quickly introduced to Darrell’s fundamental flaw that she battles with through the books – her temper.
She is quite handy with the slaps and pushes though, something that would be frowned on even more today.
We learn, with her, to look past the surface to see the person underneath. I’d forgotten that Darrell and Sally weren’t immediately best friends. Sally’s behaviour really was quite odd – the sibling rivalry seemed very exaggerated and she does almost turn into a different (and much more likeable character) at the end. And ‘quick-witted Alicia, isn’t quite as fun as we first thought, the scene where she can’t hear after a swimming lesson does make you feel for her though.
I love the scene that shows how close Darrell is to her Dad – the relief she feels by him being close.
I don’t like the spider chapter, for obvious reasons *shivers*.

I think the boarding school concept was so alien to me that it was instantly appealing (though I would have hated being away from home). And when I read Harry Potter a few years later it definitely tapped into my previous MT love.

Second Form at Malory Towers (4 out of 5 stars)
One thing that confuses me is how girls move in and out of years. Having to do so many terms but all attending the same classes.
The introduction of the scatterbrained art loving Belinda in this book adds extra fun. Her friendship with Irene makes me giggle.
Gwendoline gets a taste of her own medicine by friending Daphne, but this only shows her up further when Daphne develops at the end. The scene where Daphne goes to look for sweet Mary Lou is one of my favourites from the series.

Third Year at Malory Towers (5 out of 5 stars)
One of my favourites – more new characters are introduced. Bill and her horse Thunder, Zerelda and her hair, Mavis and her voice.
Bill’s headbutting with Miss Peters with its slight twist.
The introduction of Lacrosse – I actually had a desire to participate in a sport – not that I’ve ever got too.

Upper Fourth at Malory Towers (3 out of 5 stars)
My least favourite book. Too much infighting and jealousy as Darrell is in charge of the form for School Cert year. Darrell’s temper strikes again.
Her younger sister Felicity joins Malory Towers and Alicia’s cousin June immediately starts bossing her around.
Belinda’s attempts at adding drawings of Gwendoline’s scowls to her collection provides light relief.
This is the book with the midnight feast down by the pool, the best part of boarding school is the midnight feast and it takes until the fourth book to get one.

In the Fifth at Malory Towers (5 out of 5 stars)
Come on, this one had to be my favourite – it involves Darrell discovering her love of writing when the girls put on the end of term entertainment for the school and parents. A pantomime of Cinderella and yay Mary Lou gets to shine.
Mamzelle also plays her treek with the teeth that had me chuckling along with her.

Last Term at Malory Towers (4 out of 5 stars)
Two of our favourite characters are head girl of the school and games captain as they come to terms with leaving Malory Towers.
The older girls get their own studies.
Amanda, a new girl and potential Olympian takes June under her wing. She also puts herself in danger. Malory Towers tends to stop those who think they’re too big for their own boots being that way for long. The only one who never really seems to learn is Gwendoline. However I’ve since found out that the series has been continued in another six books by Pamela Cox and in it Gwendoline Mary is a teacher!!!
Expect reviews of the following at some point.
New Term at Malory Towers
Summer Term at Malory Towers
Winter Term at Malory Towers
Fun and Games at Malory Towers
Secrets at Malory Towers
Goodbye Malory Towers

Daddy will you read to me?

 ‘Only one in eight dads take the lead with reading to their children’

I have to admit to being both shocked and not shocked to hear this statistic.

Research interviews suggested that fathers see ‘reading as a female domain’ and tend not to use the resources or follow the practices that mothers do. It is also suggested that when they do read they read more to their daughters than their sons – therefore perpetuating the cycle.

Booktrust report this as ‘a major concern as a father’s involvement in their child’s early reading is proven to boost academic success, leading to improved social and emotional wellbeing’.

Now I agree with some of the comments on the campaign page which suggest that leading reading should be a shared responsibility but I think the concern is about men modelling reading as desirable, particularly to boys. The Booktrust campaign ‘Get Dads Reading’ is therefore challenging dads to match mums in reading. Why not even read and spend quality time all together.

HRH, The Duchess of Cornwall and author James Patterson launched the campaign. Here is James talking about it.

I learnt that James started writing for children to encourage his son to read. He also has his own website ReadKiddoRead that acts as a resource to help parents find books their children might like, and provides lesson plans and activities for educators.

Working late got much of the blame for the lack of reading to children, and research is suggesting ‘that at formal literacy events for children, only 10% of the parents attending are dads.’ This makes me wonder how much support our culture and therefore employers give dads to attend school events such as these.

Writer Matt Haig shares his views here. He suggests the ratio of women to men reading in general is 70:30 and also highlights this is a wider cultural issue with book marketing being directed more to women because they buy more. That capitalism effect again!!

My memory is rubbish so I have no actual recollection of either of my parents reading to me (I barely know what happened to me a month ago so I’m 100% sure they did – ‘I remember’ practicing writing the letters of the alphabet before school and I remember reading lots as a child). What I do recall is both my parents with their nose in a book, laid in bed together or side by side in armchairs reading, Dad bringing one with him in the car when he was taking me for an appointment somewhere. My parents love of reading has clearly rubbed off on me (I used to get told off for spending too much time on the loo with a book!!).

I’m sure I don’t need to tell you that I think reading is important for development and wellbeing – I’m almost suspicious of those who say they don’t like reading often wanting to find and suggest books that will “change their minds”.

If you are/or know a dad who takes up the challenge tweet using the hashtag #dadsreading. Believe me your children will thank you for it – eventually.

(Much of the information above comes from a Booktrust press release and I’ve tried to indicate where I used their words).

One thing I wondered when it was mentioned that boys’ literacy is falling was about the impact of this on dads’ reading. Another campaign I’ve heard Kara Tointon talking about recently is Quick Reads. This is where major authors have been commissioned to write shorter stories targeted at the 1 in 6 people who find reading challenging (Kara has dyslexia and on a recent radio show she reported feeling jealous of her sister reading when younger and really enjoying reading when she finally got into it).

You can find out more about Quick Reads and how to purchase the books here.

I’m hoping to interview Rosi Crawley from Booktrust soon, to find out more about the organisation and their work. I’m giving her a couple of weeks to settle into her new job though (Rosi was previously the giver of lovely ARCs at HarperCollins and sent me the press release for this campaign).

Please share with me your #dadsreading stories below?

Insurgent – Book Review (May Contain Spoilers)

The day has finally arrived – 1st May 2012 – publication day for Veronica Roth’s sequel to Divergent. Insurgent is the second book of a planned trilogy and just as enticing as the first. The Tagline for Insurgent is:

I have done bad things. I can’t take them back, and they are part of who I am.

As part of Team Abnegation UK (a book blogger challenge), I was treated to an Advanced Review Copy (ARC) of Insurgent – thanks HarperCollins. I only received my copy on Wednesday but being selfless (as the abnegation are) I still made it a priority to read the book so that I could review it for you today. In the process I managed to cross another thing off my Bucket List.

The first thing I would say is that you really need to read Divergent if you haven’t already – you can find my review of it here. And you can buy it on the sponsored link below:

But, if you have already read Divergent and haven’t got time to read it again before Insurgent (I didn’t but wish I had) – the lovely lady herself has been kind enough to provide a summary of what happened in the first book here.

I’m afraid I’m going to find it really hard to review without some spoilers for Divergent if not Insurgent. I’ll try really hard not to give away everything but if you prefer not to read the review it is contained within the stars below.

***

Insurgent picks up exactly where Divergent left off with Tris and Four/Tobias and ‘whoever else was with them’ on a train on their way to the Amity compound and the action is pretty much non stop from then though there is food and sleep mentioned ;o).
In Divergent we only really got to meet three of the five factions – Abnegation (the selfless) where Tris was raised, Dauntless (the brave) where she transfers to and Erudite (the intelligent) where her brother Caleb transfers to. They are also the faction responsible for the devastation at the end of Divergent.
In Insurgent we get to visit the headquarters of all factions and find out more about Amity (the peaceful) and Candor (the honest) in the process. We also find out that the factionless are more organised than they have clearly been given credit for.

Tris is dealing with the repercussions of what she did during the Erudite controlled Dauntless simulations as well as what happened to her parents and old and current faction members. I think it is more evident to us in this book than the last that she is only 16. She is impatient and impulsive but also inquisitive and she shows her Abnegation roots by her numerous acts of selflessness. It’s unfortunate that these acts usually see others placed in danger too. Tris and Four do not have a love triangle to contend with but they also do not have a smooth ride as a couple and both keep secrets that threaten their relationship.

Divergence is seen as a massive threat by the Erudite and, not content with trying to wipe out Abnegation, they try to determine a way to control or eliminate the Divergent. We find out that Divergence is more rife than we first thought and that means something for the future of society as Tris knows it. She knows her parents wanted to let everyone know the truth and Tris doesn’t want their deaths to have been in vain. Now I had kind of guessed what the truth might be but that didn’t spoil the big reveal for me (and I got a little confused at one thing – hence the recommendation to re-read Divergent if you can or have a better memory than me).

I’m really looking forward to seeing that truth open up a whole new avenue for exploration in the as yet unnamed trilogy concluder.

As with Divergent I have selected a few of my favourite quotes to illustrate some of the themes/images that stood out for me with a little explanation why.

His breaths, my breaths, his body, my body, we are so close there is no difference.

As I mentioned in my X post there are some slightly raunchy scenes in Insurgent where Tris and Four get a little bit steamy. For Tris these moments with Tobias are her escape from the collapse of society around her and this line represents that perfectly. She never lets herself escape completely though and Tobias remains the perfect gentleman.

…even more difficult to justify my feelings with no evidence except my intuition.
    So I agree. But I do not change my mind.

Often quotes jump out at me because they may resonate with my life outside the book. To me this demonstrates the difficulties many of us face with a lack of acceptance of certain forms of knowledge. That thoughts and feelings and intuition are still not as accepted as what we can see or add up. Tris has no idea what the ‘truth’ may be but she ‘knows’ that it needs to be set free.

Don’t tell me you’re going to eat a mashed-potato sandwich

This made me giggle – Tris asks this almost indignantly of another character but it just made me crave a mash potato sandwich. I’ve not had one for a good few years now.  

Blood is a strange color. It’s darker than you expect it to be.

Obviously this comes at a point when Tris has already seen more than her fill of blood but to me it acknowledges her humanity. Death doesn’t become easier for her to accept just more of a reality.   

I don’t stare back – I refuse to stare back.
    I stare back.

Just love the contradiction in this. When we really try to stop ourselves we just can’t help giving in to what we are resisting.  

I think we cry to release the animal parts of us without losing our humanity.

I’ve been someone who has battled crying all my life, crying when I am sad, angry or sometimes with relief (A-Level results) or in pure fear (The Woman in Black). I am coming to terms with the fact that this is necessary for me, even though it sometimes makes others uncomfortable. I even have times when I haven’t cried for a when I feel an overwhelming need for a good blub. I love how Veronica through Tris justifies the necessity of this act for me.

I think they’re going to force us to eat lots of cake and then take an unreasonably long nap.

In the face of fear what is the best course of action – laugh. Tris lies to a Candor born Dauntless and comes out with my idea of heaven.

***

Over the week the rest of my team will be reviewing the book on their respective blogs – you can find a list of them on this post here.

(Abnegation Image courtesy of serendipity_viv)

(Three birds Image courtesy of my invite e-mail from HarperTeen - a representation of Tris' tattoo?)

You can buy Insurgent on the sponsored link below (I’m still going to be buying the Kindle version despite my ARC):

Or just admire my copy of the book from the day it arrived. I strongly suggest reading it though.

Finally in honour of today my 366 Photo (incidentally 1/3 of the way through the challenge) represents the grey stones of Abnegation.

I’d really love to hear what you thought of Insurgent in the comments – as a consequence readers please be aware the comments may contain spoilers.

In honour of Abnegation I’d also like you you tell me what selfless acts you’ve performed recently. Mine usually revolve around letting people out in front of me in the car or helping people with their IT related difficulties.

Happy Reading!