E is for…Ethics #AtoZChallenge

E is for… Ethics

Before I can start collecting data for my research I need to submit a research proposal to an ethical review board at my university.

The seven principles of ethical research as outlined by the College of Occupational Therapists (2003) are:

Minimising Potential Harm
Maximising Benefit
Respect/Equality/Partnership
Autonomy
Honesty, Integrity and Openness
Impartiality and Fairness
Confidentiality and Anonymity

So, as you can see, Ethics isn’t just about not hurting people, though of course that is very important. It is also about ensuring quality of work (e.g. that the methodology matches the aim/research question) and reviewing that even at the start of research the researcher has considered methods of disseminating that research (not just abandoning it in the thesis section of their university library).

I’m just going to highlight a couple of ethical challenges my research presents below. There is much more to consider than just these though.

Ethical challenges in Qualitative research

With qualitative research it can be very difficult at the start of the research to say exactly what the methods will look like because qualitative research often tends to be an interactive process which constantly involves depending on responses from participants. I am lucky in the fact that my university is used to dealing with qualitative research and therefore appreciates that the design will be emergent (Bailliard et al 2013). This is not, however, an excuse for me not to think about the detail. Bailliard et al (2013 p 160) suggest using a road map that highlights a general direction and goal but leaves some flexibility in the route. In terms of using a writing analogy I like to think of this as a rough but flexible plot outline.

When exploring people’s lives there is always the potential to bring up issues that they may find emotive or distressing and so it will be relevant to give advice on counselling services, etc. In fact I think it is important as a qualitative researcher to consider the same for yourself.

Ethical challenges in Autoethnography

When writing autoethnography (as I intend to) you will inevitably identify other people in your life in your writing. How to manage this will be something I need to consider (including issues such as asking them for consent). Even if names are changed, because I am naming myself, people who know me may be able to work out who those people are.
Because I am planning to work with others I need to address their anonymity – do they wish to be named and if so are they aware of potential consequences.
One way round some of these issues may be to create storied amalgams but then this may ‘interrupt’ the flow of the stories told by mixing up or leaving out crucial details that may be vital to developing a fuller understanding of issues.

Some General Practical Considerations
If you are asked to participate in research (I have been a few times now) – do check these things.
You should be given what is generally known as a ‘Participant Information Sheet’ which tells you about the research and what you will be expected to do. You should also be given the opportunity to ask any questions you don’t think have been covered.
Types of information that this commonly includes:
where ethical consent to undertake the research was gained,
details about the researcher and their qualifications,
details about the research aim/questions (though in some cases it may be appropriate to not go into too much depth here in case it influences the outcomes of the study),
details about what will happen to the information you share, e.g. how it will be stored, who will see it, how your confidentiality and anonymity will be protected,
the statement that you are free to withdraw from the study at any time without prejudice (this is especially important if you are participating in a clinical study).

Following reading this you should also be asked to sign a consent form.

Here’s a personal example: I participated in an asthma study where I had allergy testing and sat in a cubicle to try and induce my asthma symptoms. During routine medical checks they discovered a heart murmur and gave me relevant advice to get this all checked. They would have to have considered aspects like this when getting the study agreed. My murmur was all benign in case you were wondering.

References

Bailliard, A.L., Aldrich, R.M. and Dickie, V.A. (2013) Ethnography and the Transactional Study of Occupation. In Cutchin, M.P., and Dickie, V.A. (eds) (2013) Transactional Perspectives on Occupation. London: Springer, pp. 157 − 168.

College of Occupational Therapists (2003) Research Ethics Guidelines. London: College of Occupational Therapists.

So there we have it a whistle stop tour of research ethics.

Have you ever participated in research – did you receive a participant information sheet? How did you find participating in the research?

Have you ever gone to an ethical review board to conduct research? Can you share any hints or tips?

Advertisements

Posted on April 5, 2013, in April A-Z Challenge, Occupational Therapy, PhD and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. 17 Comments.

  1. I find ethical conversations endlessly fascinating as there can be lots of things factoring into the decision making process. Sometimes with big issues it can be very murky ground indeed. My teenager could have studied ethics as an option at school and I was desperate for it to do it, so I could do it vicariously, but it wasn’t to be. A great subject.

  2. I just recently began taking a course on research methods. I haven’t gotten far enough into it yet to be able to really comment in depth about what it says about ethics but I expect that to be a very big part of the learning objectives LOL I’ll let you know once I’ve gone deeper into the material 🙂

  3. I was a part of a 3 hours focus group once and got paid $75. It was really cool. I had to fill out info about myself and there were only about 20 other women in the room. Turned out to be a political thing, but was very neat.

    • The concept about payment for taking part in research is interesting. Of course participants shouldn’t be out of pocket so expenses should be covered but I wonder if there is a possibility payment could influence what is said. Conversely it can be hard to get people to take part sometimes so payment might be needed. See it’s a minefield. I wonder how things vary between countries in regards to this.

      Thanks for commenting.

  4. I always knew ethics were important, didn’t realize just how deep it all ran. Nice to meet you during the A to Z.
    A2Z Mommy And What’s In between

  5. Jagoda Perich-Anderson, M.A.

    Ethics are so important not only in research but in life, and yet sometimes so slippery (gray areas and all). That’s what makes thinking about them endlessly fascinating and worth figuring out. Informative post.
    Jagoda from the A to Z Challenge at http://www.conflicttango.com

  6. I’d love to be able to answer your questions but at the moment I am currently trying to avoid having to embark on my PhD! *runs away*

    • Sorry to chase you away – I do completely understand that reaction ;o) – Anyway you are busy being writer in residence which sounds like lots of fun.

  7. I haven’t participated in any serious research. Ethics are a subject that needs more attention in every part of the world.

    • Yes, especially in *coughs and mutters into hand* politics. It can be really interesting to take part in research. Another study I am involved in is one into mobile phone use. Basically I had to give permission for the reviewers to look at my phone records and medical records and need to make sure my contact details are up to date every now and again. It is important because we don’t really know the health effects.

  1. Pingback: E is for…Ethics #AtoZChallenge | hOT New...

Please share your thoughts with me!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: